Caffeine.supply

Top 10 Chocolatey Specialty Coffees

Top 10 coffees · 2026 · Ranked by expert rating

Chocolatey coffees deliver cocoa depth, from milk chocolate sweetness to dark chocolate intensity. They are the crowd-pleasers of specialty coffee: low in acidity, round in body, and at home in espresso, lattes, and French press. These are the highest-rated coffees in our catalog tagged with a chocolate flavor profile.

#1
Decaf Mexico by Temple Coffee Roasters
Temple Coffee Roasters
Decaf Mexico
Mexico · $18.00
★ 4.8Swiss Water Process DecafMedium Roast
›
#2
Synthesis by Ceremony Coffee Roasters
Ceremony Coffee Roasters
Synthesis
Colombia · $21.00
★ 4.8WashedMedium-Dark Roast
›
#3
Rwanda Muhororo Ireme Anaerobic Natural by Onyx Coffee Lab
Onyx Coffee Lab
Rwanda Muhororo Ireme Anaerobic Natural
Rwanda · $21.50
Sold Out★ 4.8Anaerobic NaturalLight Roast
›
#4
El Salvador Las Mercedes Pacamara Honey by Klatch Coffee
Klatch Coffee
El Salvador Las Mercedes Pacamara Honey
El Salvador · $22.95
★ 4.8HoneyMedium Roast
›
#5
Mexico Mazateca by Vigilante Coffee
Vigilante Coffee
Mexico Mazateca
Mexico · $23.00
★ 4.8WashedMedium Roast
›
#6
Kenya Elshadai Coffee Estate Natural by Onyx Coffee Lab
Onyx Coffee Lab
Kenya Elshadai Coffee Estate Natural
Kenya · $27.00
Sold Out★ 4.8NaturalLight Roast
›
#7
Panama Elida Estate Falda Anaerobic by Onyx Coffee Lab
Onyx Coffee Lab
Panama Elida Estate Falda Anaerobic
Panama · $148.00
★ 4.8Anaerobic NaturalLight Roast
›
#8
Nicaragua La Negrita CM Natural by Flight Coffee
Flight Coffee
Nicaragua La Negrita CM Natural
Nicaragua · $15.60
★ 4.7Carbonic Maceration NaturalLight Roast
›
#9
Organic Tomorrow Seasonal Project Peru by Ruby Coffee Roasters
Ruby Coffee Roasters
Organic Tomorrow Seasonal Project Peru
Peru · $16.40
★ 4.7WashedMedium Roast
›
#10
Blue Orchid Blend by Huckleberry Roasters
Huckleberry Roasters
Blue Orchid Blend
Central & South America · $19.25
★ 4.7Washed, NaturalMedium Roast
›

See all coffees from this category: /coffee/chocolatey/

Top 10 Chocolatey Specialty Coffees FAQ

What is the #1 coffee in "Top 10 Chocolatey Specialty Coffees"?
Decaf Mexico by Temple Coffee Roasters currently ranks first with a rating of 4.8. The list updates automatically as ratings in our catalog change.
How are these coffees ranked?
Coffees are ordered by expert rating, with ties broken by catalog data. The 10 coffees here range from 4.7 to 4.8 and average 4.8. There are no paid placements.
How much do the top 10 coffees cost?
Bag prices on this list run from $15.60 to $148.00.
Which roasters and origins appear most?
The list features 8 different roasters, and Mexico is the most common origin (2 of 10).